Varnish rarely gives up all at once. It usually starts with a small nick, picked up coming alongside a wall or a pontoon, that lets moisture in. Left alone, the moisture works in behind the finish and the varnish starts to lift around the damage.
Woodwork divides owners. Some love the maintenance and the tinkering on board. Others just want to get on and use the boat, without the hassle of looking after the timber, no matter how nice it looks. This piece covers where the wood is, where its finish fails, what keeping on top of it involves and how I go about the work.
Where the wood is on a Pilot
On a Pilot built today, the timber is typically, but not exclusively, the rubbing strakes, locker tops and the rudder and tiller. Some boats carry a timber mast, quarter badges, lower rubbing strakes or other timber embellishments as well.
Every Pilot is built to order, so an owner can have as much or as little timber as they like. Some have a little more and some a little less. That has not changed a great deal over the years.
Plymouth Pilots built before 1989 are a different matter. Many have timber bulkheads, timber floors and sometimes a timber engine box, so there can be quite a lot of wood to look after. This piece is about the timber you can see and the finish that protects it. The structural timber underneath, such as the floor bearers, is a subject of its own, covered in What Is the Lifespan of a Fibreglass Boat?
Where varnish fails first
Varnish will always fail where water sits on it.
On a Pilot, the places to watch are either end of the cover. Those areas stay wet after the rest has dried, and the finish there breaks down first. There is more on covers in Laying Up for Winter.
The other place is the joint between the ring deck, our term for the moulded gunwale, and the woodwork. That joint is sealed, and the sealant will fail in time. It is UV stabilised, but general wear and tear and environmental factors degrade it. Once it goes, water has a route in behind the timber.
A lot of the damage done to varnish is not done over the summer. It is done over the winter, when the weather is wetter and the timber does not get the opportunity to dry out.
Using the boat regularly helps, because it gives you the chance to keep the woodwork clean and to spot damage while it is small.
The mistake I see most
One of the mistakes I see most is owners simply ignoring their varnish and expecting it to go on looking nice. Varnish needs maintenance, perhaps not every year but every couple of years, and in between it needs any damage dealing with.
Damage is the main one. A nick left unsealed is where the lifting starts.
If there is no time to deal with it properly during the season, I would seal it with a couple of coats of varnish. It will not necessarily look the prettiest, but it buys the time to do a nice job of it over the winter.
Varnish, oil or left bare
Our timber is now iroko, though earlier Pilots used teak. Both are naturally oily, hard-wearing hardwoods, which is why they can be left bare: untreated, they weather to a silvery grey rather than rot. Teak weathers better than iroko, which is one reason iroko is more often varnished.
We finish the timber however the owner wants it, and it is very much down to personal preference. Some owners like the weathered look and keep the timber bare or oiled. Bare timber is best washed down gently, as heavy scrubbing wears it away. I think it looks quite nice.
Oil soaks into the timber and helps keep water out from within, rather than creating a protective layer on top. It gives less protection than varnish, but it cannot peel or lift, so keeping it up is just a case of wiping on more oil rather than sanding back. Over the years we have used teak oil as well as varnish.
Others prefer varnish, and with that comes the upkeep. Varnish builds a clear, hard layer on the surface that keeps water out and, with a UV filter, protects the timber from the sun. It gives the most protection and the glossiest finish, but only while that layer is unbroken, which is why a small nick matters. Sometimes the owner specifies the varnish, otherwise our go-to is Epifanes Woodfinish Gloss.
How I go about it
Some guides suggest recoating varnish annually, before it shows any sign of failing. My own feeling is different.
Nine times out of ten, if you keep on top of damage during the course of the year, a maintenance coat over the winter is not a bad thing. It is not always necessary.
When a number of sections start to lift or show damage, a maintenance coat will not bring it back. At that point it all has to come off and you start again. It is not an overly difficult job, it is just one of time.
The work falls into three jobs. Sealing damage is a quick job in the season. A maintenance coat is a day over the winter. Taking it back to bare wood is the long one.
Sealing a nick during the season
- Wash the area with fresh water and a little mild soap. Varnish will not stick properly to salt or dirt.
- Let it dry completely. Varnish over damp timber seals in the moisture you are trying to keep out.
- Lightly sand the damaged spot and just around it, with the grain, to give the new varnish something to key to. I use 220 to 320 grit.
- Apply a couple of coats of varnish with a small brush, letting each dry before the next.
A winter maintenance coat
- Wash the woodwork down and let it dry. Varnish needs the right conditions to cure: Epifanes gives a minimum of 8°C and no more than 75% humidity, out of direct sun and wind, so in winter this is a job for under cover.
- Mask the ring deck and anything else next to the timber, so sanding scratches and varnish stay off the gelcoat.
- Rub the whole surface down lightly with 220 to 320 grit to key it, paying attention to anywhere that has started to lift. Wipe the dust off with a tack cloth.
- Apply one thin coat of varnish, thinned by about 10% for a good grip, brushing with the grain.
With the prep and the masking, that is a day's work.
Taking it back to bare wood
- Soften the old varnish with a chemical remover suited to marine use, following the manufacturer's instructions, or with heat. With heat, take real care to protect the gelcoat and any painted surfaces next to the timber.
- Scrape the softened varnish off, then sand the bare timber with the grain to 180 grit. Wear a dust mask when sanding iroko, as the dust can cause allergic reactions.
- Make sure the surface is completely free of old varnish and dust before anything goes on. Iroko and teak are oily timbers, so wipe the bare wood down with thinners to degrease it before the first coat.
- Build the varnish back up over six coats: a first coat thinned by about 25% so it soaks into the grain, then five more. Sand lightly between coats with 220 to 320 grit and follow the manufacturer's recoat times.
- Once the varnish work is finished, reseal the joint between the woodwork and the ring deck.
Choosing less wood
Not every owner wants to spend that time. Timber rubbing strakes can be swapped for PVC or rubber without any problems. They are relatively easy to remove and refit.
I do not think many owners regret it. When a Pilot is ordered new, we go through the pros and cons of timber against PVC. By then owners usually have quite a strong idea of how much maintenance they want to take on. Who the woodwork suits, and who it does not, is part of Why a Plymouth Pilot Might Be the Wrong Boat for You.
Others inherit more wood than they would have chosen themselves. One owner commented recently that he had bought his boat from two young boatbuilders who had refurbished it using rather more wood than average, and the result was the prospect of a lot more work to keep on top of the varnish.
What the wood really asks for
The timber work does not ask for a lot, other than a little regular care. Varnish will fail with age eventually, but it often fails well before that point: where water is left to sit, where it has been nicked, where the sealant has failed or in areas that are kept damp.